Learning Hub Article

Which Kitchen Extractor Fan is Best for my Project?

The best kitchen extractor depends on your kitchen layout, the position of your hob and your property’s ventilation requirements. Ceiling-mounted, downdraft and traditional cooker hood systems each offer different advantages. Choosing the right solution early in the kitchen design process helps balance effective extraction with the overall design.

Up, down, or round and round?

Traditionally, this task was the job of an overhead cooker hood, positioned against an external wall and expelling the air directly outside through a vent. Gradually, internal activated charcoal cleaning filters improved, capturing and purifying more of the air, negating the need to send it outside. Thus, the recirculating extractor was born, and new shapes and design opportunities were made possible.

For a long time, an overhead cooker hood was the most effective way to clear the air above the hob. Appliance manufacturers, including Gaggenau, Sub-Zero Wolf and Miele, developed downdraft extractors that rose up from the worktop. These monolithic extractors looked impressive but proved costly and consumed valuable storage space compared to their overhead counterparts.

How extractor design has changed

Overhead cooker hoods remain a reliable option, but extractor designs now include rising downdrafts, modular worktop systems, and induction hobs with integrated extraction.

Current examples range from the BORA X Pure PUXA2 and PUXU2 integrated cooktop extractors to the Gaggenau VL 414 115 modular downdraft. These systems can keep walls and ceilings visually clear, but they require space below the worktop for the motor, filters or ducting.

Drawer depth, cabinet storage, service access, and the route for discharged or recirculated air should therefore be addressed at the outset of kitchen design.

BORA currently identifies PUXA2 as its exhaust-air X Pure model and PUXU2 as the recirculating version. Gaggenau’s VL 414 115 is a current motorless modular downdraft designed to work with a separate remote fan unit.

When working on new-build projects, we often tend to specify a recirculating extractor with an MVHR. This is a more environmentally friendly option because, rather than venting all the heated air in your house outside (which then needs to be replenished and reheated), a recirculating system keeps that heated air and sends it back into the room.

New-build homes are generally more airtight, so an externally ducted extractor should be coordinated with the property’s wider ventilation and replacement-air strategy. Older homes may have greater natural air leakage, but their ventilation requirements should still be assessed rather than assumed.

The appropriate solution depends on the extractor’s airflow, the property’s ventilation system, the presence of any combustion appliances and the overall building design. These points should be resolved with the relevant kitchen, ventilation and construction professionals before the appliance is specified.

How do you choose the right extraction method and model for your kitchen?

BORA cooktop with integrated downdraft extraction

Integrated Downdraft

Open-plan bulthaup kitchen island beneath a flush ceiling-mounted extractor

Cooker hood

Stainless-steel ceiling-mounted extractor above a kitchen island.

Ceiling Mounted

Flush built-in ceiling extractor above a bulthaup b3 island.

Built in

 


At Hobson’s Choice, we recommend extractors from manufacturers such as Westin, Wolf, Gaggenau, Siemens, Miele, and BORA. Early in the design process, you will explore one or more of our showrooms and learn about the different types of extractor technology on display. You will also see finished projects on our website that utilise different extractor models.

What you choose depends on what you want to achieve in designing your new kitchen. These criteria can help you define the right choice for you.


 

What is the Volume of your Kitchen Space?

Guidance suggests that a kitchen extractor should be capable of refreshing the room’s air 10 times per hour. The size of this task is calculated by multiplying the room’s length, width, and height, then multiplying the result by 10. This gives you the cubic volume of air the extractor will move per hour (m³/h).

If you have a large open-plan space, you may wish to consider an extractor with a suitable capacity. The table shows the manufacturer-quoted figures for the extractors featured in this article. The figures quoted are for the highest normal setting, not the boosted setting, which you would be unlikely to run for extended periods.

Where would you like to position the extractor?


Kitchen island

Cooking on an island and looking into the kitchen/living space can be a very pleasing and desirable design attribute. The layout lends itself to a more social, engaging environment, where the cook and guests can converse face-to-face without having to turn away.

This layout lends itself to all types of ventilation, although ducting can be more challenging than recirculation due to the channelling required for the pipework, underfloor or within the ceiling.

In addition, if the ducting length exceeds a certain limit, the airflow generated by the motor will be too slow to operate efficiently. A second ‘remote’ motor would need to be fitted outside to help pull the air through.


 

bulthaup b3 kitchen integrated downdraft cooktop extraction

Integrated downdraft

An integrated downdraft places extraction close to the cooking surface and keeps the walls and ceiling visually clear. The motor, filters or ducting require space below the worktop, which may reduce drawer depth or island storage.

Recirculating models also require ongoing odour-filter maintenance, while ducted versions need a suitable route to the outside.

bulthaup b3 kitchen at Hobson's Choice Wiltshire design studio

Cooker hood

A wall- or island-mounted cooker hood places the capture area above the hob and can be specified for exhaust-air or recirculating operation.

It remains a visible element in the room and must be installed at the manufacturer’s stated height. A ducted version requires an external route; a recirculating version requires odour-filter maintenance and returns the filtered air to the room.

Recessed ceiling extractor installed above a demonstration cooktop

Ceiling-mounted extractor

A ceiling-mounted extractor keeps the worktop clear and can work well above an island.

It requires suitable ceiling depth or a purpose-made enclosure, together with safe access for cleaning and servicing. Because the appliance is positioned farther from the cooking surface, the precise mounting height, room air movement and selected model performance need careful consideration.

External Wall

The most efficient way of positioning a ducted extractor is on an external wall because it minimises the distance the unwanted air must travel. However, being this definitive can adversely impact a design layout and conflict with the most favourable user experience. In some cases, it may be impossible to position an extractor on an exterior wall due to the space’s architecture.

When faced with this challenge, a recirculating wall-mounted extractor would be a suitable alternative and could be freely positioned.

Is your property listed or have any restrictions that would cause a problem installing ducting in the floor or ceiling?

In a listed property, there are often restrictions that can affect extraction opportunities; floors, walls, or ceilings may be protected by the listed status and may not be touched or altered. This may also be true in apartment buildings.

Before commencing, it is recommended that the parameters of any building are explored to ensure no issues arise later. It is expected that your designer would raise these questions as part of the design process.

Do you want to keep your ceiling and/or walls free from obstruction?

A wall- or island-mounted hood places the capture area relatively close to the cooking surface. It remains a visible part of the room, which may provide a deliberate focal point or may not suit a more visually restrained scheme. The selected hood must also be positioned at the manufacturer’s specified height and coordinated with the lighting, ceiling and sightlines through the room.


Does your kitchen space link directly into an open-plan living area?


How noisy is a kitchen extractor?

In an open-plan space, noise can become a greater contributing factor when choosing a suitable extractor. Whilst the cook is working, other members of the household may be having an online video meeting, watching TV, or enjoying music, all in the same room.

The details below show the manufacturer-quoted noise range of each extractor featured in this article, from the lowest to the boost settings. As a guide, a normal conversation is around 60 decibels (dB), and a vacuum cleaner is around 75 dB.

  • Westin Prime Slim, 900 mm, internal motor – Airflow rating: 800 m³/h Maximum: 70 dB at speed 4/boost
  • Miele DAC 4940 Stella Ambient, exhaust-air mode Normal: – 235–505 m³/h; boost: 680–755 m³/h Sound power, normal: 42–59 dB(A); boost: 66–68 dB(A)
  • BORA X Pure PUXA2, exhaust-air model Normal: – 182–549 m³/h; intensive: 597 m³/h Sound power, normal: 42–67 dB; intensive: 69 dB 
  • Gaggenau VL 414 115 with AR 403 122 remote fan configuration: performance depends on the selected remote fan. For normal-mode sound level: 57–71 dB, the VL 414 115 is motorless.

Where the selected product supports it, a remote motor can move some motor noise away from the kitchen. Air movement at the intake and through the duct remains audible, so it should not be presented as a silent solution. The motor arrangement, duct route and extractor should be designed together

The extractor’s effectiveness in capturing unwanted odours at the source may also influence appliance selection. Rather than pulling the smells upwards, which offers more chance to spread, quickly sucking them downwards could reduce the overall ambient scent.

If the noise is a significant problem, a ducted extractor could be fitted with a remote motor outside the open-plan space, for example, in the loft. Relocating the motor greatly reduces noise, but this is property-dependent.

 

Technical specifications and manufacturer availability checked: 24 August 2026.


 

Cleaning and filter maintenance

All extractors require ongoing maintenance to ensure unwanted smells and odours are removed efficiently.

Grease filters need to be cleaned regularly to maintain airflow and odour removal. Appliances recommended by Hobson’s Choice would likely feature a metal grease filter allowing the units to be thoroughly washed in a dishwasher.

In a recirculating extractor, activated charcoal filters trap unwanted particles, cleaning the extracted air before it is returned to the room. The charcoal filters will need to be replaced by the owner at manufacturer-advised intervals.

In conclusion

In conclusion, the correct choice of ventilation for your kitchen project depends on your property, the design, and your individual style. There are many extractors to choose from, available in different shapes and colours, offering varying functionality across a range of price points.

When you work with us to design your next kitchen, our designers will help you filter the most suitable options into a smaller collection from which to choose your favourite. To learn more about our kitchen design services and the customer journey, click the button below.